Plato in Your Living Room

Updated, and hopefully, clarified! –JT 

Recently, in a well known address by Paul Washer, he made the following statement in reference to his seminary days:

Paul Washer “….I remember a professor walked in and he started drawing footprints on the blackboard. And as he marched them across the blackboard then he turned to all of us and said only this. “Aristotle is walking through the halls of this institution. Beware, for I hear his footsteps more clearly than those of the apostle Paul and the team of inspired men who were with him and even the Lord Jesus Christ himself.”

Plato To have the thinking of a philosopher as influential as the Word of God in a seminary, well, that’s frightening enough. Yet there is another well known philosopher who has affected the church even closer to home than the seminary.  There is a more frightening thought than Aristotle in the halls of a seminary, I think, and that would be Plato in your living room.

Over the years, I have encountered many people who have been unknowingly affected in their thinking by this man. In fact, Plato has so infiltrated the professing, visible church of today it is truly amazing. How so?

Now let me draw on my education as a classical studies student here. Greek Platonism basically holds there are two worlds. The first is a material world you can see, the other is spiritual, invisible.

According to Greek Platonism, this visible, material world is evil. The soul is trapped, it hates the body and longs for the world from which it came. The church father, Origen is considered by many as a student of Platonic philosophy. He took this concept and ran with it, so to speak. But is it biblical? And how has it affected us today?

When you think of a person, what is the most important part of that person? The soul and it’s later destiny? Is that biblical?

John MacArthur has noted: “Now philosophical dualism is basically attributed to Plato.  And philosophical dualism dominated Greek thinking….To Plato a resurrection with the body, a rejoining to a body would be like a second hell. So he denied it and Greek culture went along with it.  In fact they had a proverb.  Their proverb said, “The body is a tomb, I am a poor soul shackled to a corpse.” They thought only of the fact that the body was evil, the body was matter, the body was flesh, it would just die and you would flee away to be united with immortality.”

MacArthur continues: “Seneca, a famous Greek, said, “It pleased me to inquire into the eternity of the soul.  Nay, to believe in it.  I surrendered myself to that great hope.”  Now notice, Seneca believed in the immortality of the soul.  We find that all the  Greeks did.  They didn’t have any problem with the immortality of the soul, it was the resurrection of the body they didn’t believe in.  Seneca goes on to say, “When the day shall come which shall part this mixture of divine and human, here where I found it I will leave my body and myself I will give back to the gods.”  Now that was the typical Greek view that there was a dualism, that your spirit just went on to eternal life, your body never did.  In fact Seneca said the spirit went to be resolved into its ancient element.  And its ancient element would be God. “

Now how many professing Christians include in their concept of heaven that there will be spirits floating around, without a body? Many! Such thinking derives from Platonism, this philosophical dualism of Greek thinking.

This Greek thinking has affected many Christians view of the resurrection!

When Paul wrote to the Christians at Colossae, they were being influenced by gnostics, who taught this philosophical dualism, teaching christians that since God is spirit, He is therefore good, yet could never have anything to do with physical matter, and therefore could not be Creator of all things physical, the universe. Why, that would make God the author of evil!

This Greek thinking has affected many Christians view of God, of creation, of the biblical hope of a bodily resurrection, as well as the incarnation of Jesus Christ.

If Aristotle is so prominent in our seminaries, it does not take a great deal of imagination to see how Plato and greek philosophy as a whole has infiltrated our thinking.  By adopting various aspects of Greek philosophy over clear biblical teaching, we have arrived at prizing ‘rugged individualism’ in modern America more than Scriptural truth regarding the Church as a community.

The Church is described as a nation, a family. These are communal words. Yet we have adopted the view that not only is it permissable for a Christian to operate on their own, accountable to no one else in the church, but it is condoned if not encouraged in some circles.

Independent parachurch organizations, the emphasis on “freedom of conscience” before God, private confession of sin to God alone, answerable to no other fellowship of believers have all given rise to a self-sufficient, individualistic mentality. Where did the biblical teaching of mutual accountability go?

How many ‘one another’ passages are there in Scripture? Love, encourage, rebuke, reprove, correct, pray, confess sins to, ….all to one another. And the list goes on and on. Beloved, we have strayed so far from the Biblical idea of a church family, it’s difficult to know where to begin!

The Gospel involves far more than forgiveness of sins and going to heaven later on, as glorious as those truths are. It involves now. And the Church is not to be driven by individualistic, private thinking.  We are a spiritual and physical, visible, social order, a community that can be seen, touched, felt, shared economically within itself and opposed by the enemies of Christ!  Don’t listen to Plato. Get him out of your living room, out of your head.

The Kingdom of Christ has been established. It is you, if you are in Christ. It is not pie-in-the-sky, it is not ‘when we all get to heaven’, it is not “I just want out of this body,” it is right now, and your body is good!

Modern evangelism stresses the ‘saving of the soul’, yet the Bible teaches a person is both body and soul, and the body is good! In fact, the body is so good, that Jesus rose bodily from the dead and promises us the same thing. Thank you Plato, for confusing so many.

John Stott stated that a person is a “body-soul-in-community.” Stott is right.

The church is not a long line of invisible, individualistic IPOD/I-Phone holding lone-rangers. It is a social community, of visible members of a social structure that is countercultural to the world outside of Christ. It can be seen, and it is far from evil, as Plato suggest. Eternity does not begin when you leave your body, it has already begun! Let us be who we are now!

Bottom line, your faith is not private! You’re relationship with God Almighty is not just between you and He. Who told you that? You’re eternal destination has been changed and you desire to keep it to yourself?

You’re faith is not just between you and God, it is not private. How can we possibly be salt of the world if we stay in the proverbial shaker and tell others to stay out of our beeswax? You are accountable to me, and I to you, and we both to our Lord and Master!

I’m aware, so very aware this touches on church discipline, and mutual accountability, and so many other very important truths. But this is, at least, a starting point, and I hope to address these other issues later on, Lord willing.